Last updated: Nov 16, 2026 - odds as listed Nov 15, stats through games of Nov 14. Next update after the Nov 21 games.
Jeremiah Smith is a wide receiver, a position that accounts for four of the 91 Heisman winners, and his Ohio State team has already lost three times. He is the odds-on favorite anyway, on a board that has changed favorites twice in the last 10 days.
Here is where the prices sit, what the numbers say about each contender, and the dates that will decide it, because the voting closes before a single playoff game is played.
Heisman odds by book, as of Nov 15, 2026
| Player | FanDuel | DraftKings | BetMGM | Caesars | bet365 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State | -140 | -144 | -145 | -150 | -150 |
| Darian Mensah, QB, Miami | +350 | +340 | +375 | +330 | +350 |
| Devon Dampier, QB, Utah | +550 | +720 | +600 | +700 | +600 |
| CJ Carr, QB, Notre Dame | +1100 | +1000 | +1200 | +1000 | +1000 |
| Gunner Stockton, QB, Georgia | +2500 | +2500 | +3000 | +2000 | +2200 |
| Keelon Russell, QB, Alabama | +4500 | n/a | +5000 | +5000 | +3500 |
| Gio Lopez, QB, Wake Forest | +6000 | +5000 | +5000 | +6000 | +5000 |
| Drew Mestemaker, QB, Oklahoma State | +12500 | n/a | +12500 | +10000 | +5000 |
Sources: FanDuel, BetMGM (except Smith), Caesars and bet365 from the VegasInsider Heisman table labelled Nov 15; DraftKings from Bill Connelly at ESPN on Nov 15; BetMGM's Smith price from BetMGM's own blog. Prices move daily.
How the board got here
Smith opened at +1400 at BetMGM, behind Carr (+800) and a list of quarterbacks that included Arch Manning, who had drifted to around +25000 by Nov 10. Six weeks into the season Smith was -220 at DraftKings. Then Notre Dame beat Miami 31-24 on Nov 7, and by Nov 10 DraftKings had Carr as the favorite at +220, with Mensah +250 and Smith +280.
It lasted one week. Smith caught 11 passes for 117 yards against Northwestern on Nov 14 and went back to -144. Carr went 20-for-28 in a 41-7 win over Boston College and still drifted from +220 to +1000, per Connelly. A blowout of a weak opponent does not give voters a moment, and the market knows it.
One more detail matters for pricing. On Nov 10, with Carr briefly on top, BetMGM trading manager Seamus Magee told VegasInsider: "Smith is the most-bet player and the biggest liability to win the award." When a book is heavily exposed on one name, it has every reason to keep that price short.
Why a wide receiver favorite is unusual
The history, from heisman.com
Count the 91 winners on the official winners list (1935-2025) and you get 40 running backs, 39 quarterbacks and four wide receivers: Johnny Rodgers (1972), Tim Brown (1987), Desmond Howard (1991) and DeVonta Smith (2020). Travis Hunter, listed as CB/WR, won in 2024. Quarterbacks have won 16 of the last 20. If Jeremiah Smith wins, he is the first pure receiver to do it since DeVonta Smith.
What he has going for him, and against
He was sixth in last year's voting as a sophomore with 84 points, so voters already know the name. Ohio State already has seven Heismans, per heisman.com. Against him: Ohio State is 7-3 after losses to Texas, USC and Oregon, and Connelly sees Indiana vs UCLA as the likely Big Ten title game, with Oregon and Ohio State behind them. If Ohio State misses that game, Smith's case ends with the regular season, while rivals who reach a title game get one more stage on Dec 4-5.
The contenders' numbers, through games of Nov 14
| Player | Team (record) | Passing or receiving | Rushing | Nov 14 game |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jeremiah Smith | Ohio State (7-3) | 80 rec, 1,317 yds, 15 TD | 2 for 7 yds | 11 rec, 117 yds, 1 TD vs Northwestern |
| Darian Mensah | Miami (9-1) | 242/317, 3,076 yds, 29 TD, 2 INT | 144 yds, 2 TD | 30/41, 382 yds, 1 TD vs Duke |
| Devon Dampier | Utah (10-0) | 185/278, 2,257 yds, 22 TD, 8 INT | 582 yds, 9 TD | 204 pass, 100 rush, 4 total TD at Arizona |
| CJ Carr | Notre Dame (9-1) | 197/290, 2,385 yds, 23 TD, 2 INT | 82 yds, 3 TD | 20/28 in 41-7 win vs Boston College |
| Gunner Stockton | Georgia (9-1) | 157/220, 2,109 yds, 21 TD, 4 INT | 239 yds, 3 TD | 48-21 win vs Missouri |
Source: ESPN player stats and game logs, read Nov 16. All five have played 10 games.
Smith's case
He is second in FBS in receiving yards, 32 behind Oregon State's Jesse Legree, and has two 200-yard games: 217 yards and four touchdowns against Illinois and 206 against Iowa. That is the highlight reel voters respond to.
Mensah's case
A 76.3% completion rate, 29 touchdowns against two interceptions and a passer rating of 186.8. That rating is higher than Fernando Mendoza's 182.91 last year, though well short of Jayden Daniels' record 208.01 from 2023. He has done the last two games without his best receiver, Malachi Toney, who is recovering from ankle surgery.
Dampier, Carr and Stockton
Dampier is the quarterback of one of two unbeaten FBS teams and has 31 total touchdowns, and Utah has never had a Heisman winner. Carr has thrown two interceptions all season and taken only three sacks, but his price suggests the market thinks his best moment, the Miami win, has already passed. Stockton finished seventh in last year's voting and plays for the No. 1 team in the CFP ranking, which keeps him a live outsider if Georgia wins the SEC.
The voters versus the market
Media straw polls collected by heisman.com on Nov 10, before the latest games, did not line up with the odds. The Athletic's staff poll gave Smith 16 of 24 votes, with Carr on four. Bleacher Report had Mensah first, Carr second and Smith third. On3 had Mensah just ahead of Smith. A -140 favorite implies about 58%, which is a stronger consensus than those polls showed. If voters care more about quarterbacks on contending teams than the market does, Mensah's price is the one to watch.
What moves Heisman odds from here
Under the official balloting rules there are 931 votes in 2026: 870 media voters (145 in each of six regions), 60 living winners and one fan vote. Each ballot ranks three players, scored 3-2-1, and all three spots must be filled.
| Date | What happens |
|---|---|
| Sat Nov 21 | Ohio State at Nebraska; Miami vs Virginia Tech; Utah at TCU; Notre Dame vs SMU; Georgia at South Carolina |
| Thu Dec 3 | Ballots sent to electors |
| Fri Dec 4 - Sat Dec 5 | Conference title games; online voting opens Sat 5 p.m. ET |
| Mon Dec 7, 5 p.m. ET | Voting deadline |
| Mon Dec 7, evening | Finalists announced |
| Sat Dec 12 | Ceremony in New York on ABC (start time not yet announced) |
The deadline is the key fact. Ballots are due after conference championship weekend and before the playoff, so CFP games do not count. A quarterback who plays well in a title game on Dec 5 gets one last moment in front of voters; a player whose team is not in one does not. Expect the biggest price swings on the Saturday nights between now and Dec 5. Once ballots close at 5 p.m. ET on Dec 7, nothing on the field can change the result.
How to price a long shot
Start with implied probability. For plus odds it is 100 divided by (odds + 100): Mensah at +350 is 22.2%, Gio Lopez at +6000 is 1.6%. For minus odds it is the odds divided by (odds + 100), so Smith at -140 is 140/240, or 58.3%.
Illustration, our arithmetic: add up FanDuel's eight prices in our table and you get about 113%, before counting anyone else on the board. The extra 13 points is the book's margin. Strip it out proportionally and Smith's "fair" chance is closer to 52% than 58%. Books do not necessarily spread the margin evenly, so treat it as a rough guide.
Now the long-shot test. Say, purely as a hypothetical, you think a player has a 3% chance. The fair price for 3% is about +3233, so +6000 would be generous and +2500 would not. The arithmetic is easy; the hard part is being honest about the 3%. Shopping also matters most at the long end: Mestemaker, who leads FBS with 3,239 passing yards and 30 touchdowns, is +5000 at bet365 and +12500 at FanDuel. Same player, more than double the payout.
Long shots do win. VegasInsider lists DeVonta Smith at +10000 and Joe Burrow at +20000 before their winning seasons. But those were preseason prices. By mid-November the field has narrowed, and the books know it. Injuries also matter: Toney was the +325 third choice before his ankle injury and was then taken off the board, according to VegasInsider. Read your book's rules on how a future is settled before you bet one.
Where US bettors can bet the Heisman
The prices above come from US state-regulated books. The books below are licensed offshore, not by any US state; US regulators consider them unlicensed, and several states have ordered them to stop serving residents. Federal law such as the Wire Act targets betting businesses rather than individual bettors, but your state's law decides whether placing a bet with an unlicensed site is allowed. Check each book's restricted-states list before you deposit, and remember that gambling winnings are taxable whether or not you receive a form.
An awards future is a different bet from a stat line on a single college player, and several states ban the latter. Our college props guide covers where those rules apply. For the team side of the race, see our College Football Playoff 2026 odds, our college football bookmakers guide and the books that build same-game parlays on game lines.
Read our Bovada review and XBET review before you sign up, and confirm current bonus terms in the cashier.
Bet only what you can afford to lose. Sports betting is 21+ in most states. Set a deposit limit before you place a futures bet that will tie up money for weeks. If betting stops being fun, see our responsible gambling page, call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit ncpgambling.org.
XBET
BUSR
Sportbet.one
MyBookie
EveryGame
Bovada